Urgent: A Negative Tribunal Decision May Not Be the End. Act Before It’s Too Late.
If the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) has affirmed the Department's decision to refuse or cancel your visa, it can feel like all hope is lost. However, there is one final, highly specialised pathway that may be available: a Judicial Review in the Federal Courts.
This is not another re-hearing of your case. It is a complex legal challenge focused on errors of law made by the Tribunal. The time limits to apply for Judicial Review are absolute and incredibly short. You must seek expert legal advice immediately to determine if you have a case. Our firm has the expertise to navigate these complex court processes on your behalf.
Judicial Review is a legal process where a court examines the decision made by the Administrative Review Tribunal to determine if it contained a jurisdictional error.
A jurisdictional error occurs when the Tribunal Member:
Misunderstands or misapplies the law.
Fails to consider a relevant piece of information or considers something irrelevant.
Is not fair or unbiased in how they conduct the hearing.
Makes a decision that is illogical or irrational based on the evidence.
Essentially, the court does not decide if your visa should be granted. It only decides if the Tribunal made the decision lawfully.
Judicial Review vs. Merits Review (ART)
It is crucial to understand the fundamental difference between appealing to the ART and applying for Judicial Review.
Merits Review (ART)
The ART takes a fresh look at the facts and merits of your case. It steps into the shoes of the original decision-maker and decides what the "correct or preferable" decision is. You can present new evidence and argue the facts of your situation.
Judicial Review (Federal Court)
The Court does not look at the facts or merits. Its only concern is whether the Tribunal followed the correct legal procedure and acted within its power. You cannot present new evidence. The entire focus is on finding a legal error.
When is Judicial Review an Option?
Judicial Review is the last resort in the visa appeal process. It is only available after you have received an unsuccessful decision from a merits review tribunal like the ART. It is a pathway for situations where you believe the Tribunal itself has made a fundamental legal mistake in reaching its decision.
The Court Process and Potential Outcomes
The process for Judicial Review is a formal court proceeding, unlike the more informal Tribunal hearing.
Strict Time Limits: You have only 35 days from the date of the Tribunal's decision to lodge an application with the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.
Application Lodgement: Your lawyer will file detailed legal documents outlining the specific jurisdictional error(s) you claim the Tribunal made.
Court Hearing: Your case will be argued by a barrister before a Judge, focusing purely on legal arguments.
The Decision: If the Court agrees that a jurisdictional error occurred, it will quash (invalidate) the Tribunal's decision. The Court cannot grant your visa. Instead, it will remit (send back) your case to the ART to be decided again by a different Tribunal Member, this time according to the law as clarified by the Court.
The Decision: The ART can either affirm the original decision (it stands), vary it, set it aside and substitute a new decision (e.g., grant the visa), or remit it back to the Department to be reconsidered.
How We Can Fight for You in Court
Judicial Review is one of the most complex and specialised areas of immigration law. Success requires deep legal knowledge and experience in Federal Court litigation. Our team will:
Urgently Review Your Case: We will meticulously analyse the Tribunal's decision to identify any potential jurisdictional errors.
Provide an Honest Assessment: We will give you a clear and realistic opinion on your prospects of success in Court.
Engage Expert Barristers: We work with experienced barristers (counsel) who specialise in arguing migration matters before the Federal Courts.
Manage All Court Filings: We will prepare and lodge all necessary court documents within the strict time limits, ensuring your application is valid.
Guide You Through the Process: We will manage your case from start to finish, providing clear communication and expert guidance at every step.
Your Gateway to Australia Immigration & Legal Excellence
From visas to immigration, family, and traffic law, we guide you every step of the way.
